
Despite the lack of attention paid to dysfunction in management literature, it has always been present in our organizations, at all levels—from senior management on down. The larger the organization, the easier it is for dysfunction to lay dormant. Nothing so quickly exposes dysfunction as change which brings to the surface any number of undesirable behaviors. Suddenly, employees are forced to work for people whose shortcomings are painfully obvious.
Coping with a dysfunctional boss is far more difficult than working with a dysfunctional subordinate. Dysfunction at the lower levels impacts production, customer service, quality, materials, waste, turnover, safety, absenteeism, etc. Dysfunction at the top takes on more sinister forms like favoritism, racism, sexism, nepotism, cronyism, and ageism. These organizational characteristics affect values and culture. They defy measurement and are difficult for you to change— especially from below.
At the higher levels, dysfunction is less about performance and more about power. Functional executives use their power to move things along, to overcome obstacles and resistance to changes, and get the job done right. They focus on organizational performance through personal achievement.
In contrast, dysfunctional seniors use their power to keep things from happening while they figure out how to take the credit should something work and how to avoid responsibility should it fail. Putting previously agreed-upon actions on hold is a telltale sign of a dysfunctional decision-maker. Overriding the recommendations of subordinates and making arbitrary decisions with no explanation are additional signs of a dysfunctional boss.
The life of an organization, its principles, ethics, style, values, and morality, are shaped by the actions of those at the top. Executives, who hire their friends and relatives, overlook minorities, promote incompetent subordinates, and contract with suppliers who return favors are shaping a dysfunctional culture. Yet it would be difficult to get them to admit that such actions are demoralizing.
You may be wondering how such people reach the top of their organizations? You should also be concerned that it doesn’t happen to you on the way up. As we get into the why’s and wherefore’s, it might be helpful to keep in mind that these are not bad people, they are just dysfunctional.
Some are victims of the Peter Principle, which says that organizations tend to promote people until they reach their level of incompetence. After that, they supposedly can’t go any higher, that is, unless they have made friends with those higher up. In that case, they will continue moving up the ladder, because the old adage is true: it’s not what they know, but whom they know that counts.
Not all dysfunctional executives reached the higher levels with help from their friends. Some got there in legitimate and often laudable ways, earning their advancement through hard work and sacrifice. But now that they have reached the top, they are burned out. They want to rest on their laurels. They already “gave it their best shot” and have no more to give.
Then there are those mentally gifted individuals who were promoted because of their special knowledge and technical competence. Unfortunately, their unique skills have since become commonplace and they are no longer needed. Managers like this are stuck at a level of “unconscious incompetence.” In other words, they don’t know what they don’t know. And what’s more, they probably don’t care. They got theirs; why should they work any harder?
It is also important to realize that you may have contributed to the dysfunction at the top. How so you might ask? By withholding comments, criticisms, or concerns from your boss or by adding your own twist to information as it wends its way upward. This has become such a common practice that folks make a joke of it.
You’ve no doubt seen Dilbert cartoons posted around the office. People laugh when Dilbert and his coworkers ridicule their boss because it’s funny, but it’s also a sad commentary on life in a dysfunctional workplace. If the bosses are setting their own course and steering the ship based on contaminated information from below, it’s not totally their fault if the ship runs aground. But, they’ll get the blame anyway. Whoever said, “It’s lonely at the top” must have been an executive in a dysfunctional workplace.



